How the Full Effect of Section 377 will break many Marriage for Good

1066
Section 377

In the second half of 2018, the Supreme Court of India, passed a landmark judgment in Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of Indiai, decriminalized homosexuality, thus partially striking down Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, which made the act of sexual intercourse against the order of nature a crime.

Prior to this judgment, another landmark judgment was passed by the Gujarat High Court, earlier in the same year, Nimeshbhai Bharatbhai Desai v. State of Gujaratii, being convinced by the progressive arguments made by the divorce lawyers in Surat. In that judgment, the wife had filed an F.I.R against the husband, and charged him, among other provisions, under Section 377 of the Indian penal Code, 1860. The ruling is important in that, it did hold the husband guilty.

Online Internship with Certification
Online Internship with Certification

Important Announcement – EasyShiksha has now started Online Internship Program “Ab India Sikhega Ghar Se


How EasyShiksha Internship/Training Program Works
How EasyShiksha Internship/Training Program Works

The judgement of the Apex Court in Navtej Singh Johar, was celebrated throughout the entire nation as a revolutionary ruling in the field of constitutional law. Whereas there has been said and written about how the judgment is going to impact the lives of the LGBTQ community in India, who until then, used to live in closets and in apprehensions of their orientation, there is not enough analysis on the impact this will have on the marriages in India. This blog seeks to analyse some of those aspects in detail.

Section 13 (2) (ii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 enables a woman to file a divorce against her husband on the ground that he is guilty of having committed sodomy or bestiality, either against her or any third person.

It is important now, that we take a look at the meaning of the two words, ‘sodomy’ and ‘bestiality’. In Anil Kumar Mahsi v. Union of India1, The Supreme Court of India, held as under:

As regards sodomy, the word is defined in Black’s Law Dictionary (5th Edn.) to mean “a carnal copulation by human beings with each other against nature, or with a beast. Shorter Oxford English Dictionary defines the word ‘sodomy’ to mean “….An unnatural form of sexual intercourse, especially that of one male with another.

In R. v. D.L.W2, the judge observed as follows:

The term “bestiality” was understood to mean sodomy or buggery with an animal. Bestiality is a type/kind of sodomy.”

From the judicial interpretations of the two terms, it is clear that they are forms of sexual intercourse which are not convention or usual, (more commonly called as, ‘natural’).


Top Courses in Software Engineering

Top Courses in Software Engineering

Loading...

More Courses With Certification


Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code defines “unnatural offences” as follows:

Unnatural Offences. – Whoever voluntarily has carnal intercourse against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extent to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.”

As was observed in Anil Kumar Mahsi’s case, sodomy may mean, sex between two individuals of the same sex, that is, in essence homosexuality or the kind of sexual intercourse that was previously prohibited under the Indian Penal Code. Post the ruling of the Supreme Court in Navtej Singh Johar’s case, it is clear now that sexual intercourse between two persons of the same sex is no longer a criminal act. Likewise, other relations between and among members of the LGBTQ community are now, no longer criminal offences.

The Madras High Court in its judgment of 2nd Feb, 2016, held that homosexuality could well be a valid ground for divorce under Indian personal laws3. However, there existed a section of people that criticized the judgment saying that such a reasoning was not tenable unless and until it becomes established law that homosexuality is not a crime. Supporters of this view opined that allowing a divorce on that ground would amount to actually recognizing and acknowledging the act of homosexuality as legal, a position that was, at that time unknown to the Indian jurisprudence on the same. Even though there existed the Delhi High Court judgment of Suresh Kumar Kaushal, however, the same was subject to appeal before the Supreme Court and awaited a decision. Now that the legal position has become final with the Navtej Singh Johar judgment, there is no scope for ambiguity. Courts can legitimately allow couples to get divorce on the basis of homosexuality under Section 13 (2) (ii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and the respective provisions for the same under the various personal laws of different religions. Such an action cannot be criticized or ridiculed on the grounds of reasonability or legality. The claim that such an action would amount to officially recognizing homosexual relations, does not hold water post the ration of Navtej Johar.

This is an applaudable step in that a lot of couples had been suffering from time immemorial because of the refusal of the court to grant divorce on this ground. However, what the courts failed to realize was that forcing a homosexual person to be married to a heterosexual person, was cruel and torturous for both of them. These marriages were no more than a farce. Section 377 The sooner this façade is broken, the better it will serve the ends of justice. Now, such couple won’t have to live trapped lives and will be able to get the freedom (of choice) they always deserved. For once, the court realized that, in such cases, the true happiness of both the parties in such a marriages lies in the breaking down of the marriage and it would be wrong to even make an attempt to sustain such marriages. Such marriages are better off broken.

In fact, the Bombay High Court passed a judgment in January 2019, upholding the new view in Daniel Crasto v. State of Maharashtra.4 Judgments like these are the light of the day.

——————————————————————————————————————————————

Sign up / Register with EasyShiksha or Download the app and get free online education account. Get latest Jobs Notification & Current Affairs. You can access more than 50 free online courses, various computer and SSC Bank Railway test series and find your career options. You can Sign up with Facebook

Empower your team. Lead the industry

Get a subscription to a library of online courses and digital learning tools for your organization with EasyShiksha

Request Now
Frequently Asked Questions

Q. Are EasyShiksha's internships truly free?

Yes, all internships offered by EasyShiksha are completely free of charge.

Q. How can I apply for an internship with EasyShiksha?

You can apply by visiting our website, browsing available internships, and following the application instructions provided.

Q. What types of internships are available through EasyShiksha?

EasyShiksha offers a wide range of internships across technology, business, marketing, healthcare, and more. Opportunities are continuously updated.

Q. Will I receive a certificate upon completing an internship?

Yes, upon successful completion, you will receive a certificate recognizing your participation and achievements.

Q. Are EasyShiksha's internship certificates recognized by universities and employers?

Yes, the certificates are recognized by universities, colleges, and employers worldwide.

Q. Is the download of certificates free or paid?

Access to internships and courses is free, but there is a small fee to download certificates, covering administrative costs.

Q. When can I start the course?

You can choose any course and start immediately without delay.

Q. What are the course and session timings?

These are fully online courses. You can learn at any time and pace. We recommend following a routine, but it depends on your schedule.

Q. What will happen when my course is over?

After completion, you will have lifetime access to the course for future reference.

Q. Can I download the notes and study material?

Yes, you can access and download course materials and have lifetime access for future reference.

Q. What software/tools would be needed for the course?

All necessary software/tools will be shared during the training as needed.

Q. I’m unable to make a payment. What should I do?

Try using a different card or account. If the problem persists, email us at info@easyshiksha.com.

Q. Do I get the certificate in hard copy?

No, only a soft copy is provided, which can be downloaded and printed if required.

Q. The payment got deducted but shows “failed”. What to do?

Technical errors may cause this. The deducted amount will be returned to your account in 7-10 working days.

Q. Payment was successful but dashboard shows ‘Buy Now’?

Sometimes payment reflection is delayed. If it takes longer than 30 minutes, email info@easyshiksha.com with the payment screenshot.

Q. What is the refund policy?

If you face technical issues, you can request a refund. No refunds are issued once the certificate has been generated.

Q. Can I enroll in a single course?

Yes, select the course of interest, fill in the details, make payment, and start learning. You will also earn a certificate.

Q. My questions are not listed above. I need further help.

Contact us at info@easyshiksha.com for further assistance.

ALSO READ: GST-council-gives-a-reason-to-smile-developers

Get Course: A-complete-course-on-digital-marketing-advertising

Download this article as PDF to read offline: